The application had been submitted to the May council meeting but was deferred pending the submission of additional material which was considered necessary for the council to fully assess the proposal.

Among the concerns were the effect of dust, noise and heavy vehicle traffic on nearby residents as well as the possible impact of basting on the karst system (caves) and the impact on the ground water system. It had already been established that the quarry would not have an adverse effect on the Timor Caves.

Several nearby residents, a representative of the Newcastle Speleological Society and representatives of the proponents addressed the council prior to the application being voted and approved six votes to three.

Shire mayor Michael Johnsen said this application was the subject of a number of submissions both verbal and written which required the council’s close consideration.

“The verbal presentations from all parties involved, including councillors were appreciated and important in the assessment process,” Cr Johnsen said.

“Additionally, where expert advice was sought from other government agencies and recommendations were made, those recommendations formed part of the conditions of consent. “This way, a holistic approach was considered and advised on by the relevant experts and agencies,” he said.

Cr Johnsen acknowledged there were genuine concerns associated with the development but said the council’s conditions of consent would ensure the development could be undertaken in a sustainable manner.

Ian Vaughan, a resident who lives directly opposite the site, spoke at the council meeting and said he was concerned about the cost of up-grade works on bridges and roads to rate payers.

There are four bridges on the route and 1.4km of the road is unsealed so, Mr Vaughan questioned how much it would cost to make it stable for the use of mine trucks.